Captain America Party with the BEST Giant M&M Cookie

This shop has been compensated by Collective Bias, Inc. and its advertiser. All opinions are mine alone. #HeroesEatMMs #CollectiveBias

Captain America is not taken lightly in this house. We are huge Marvel fans – comic books, movies, video games, the whole package. Captain America though is my husband’s all time favorite. As a kid, he latched onto the idea that this little scrawny kid that no one believed in could become a hero. On the day of our wedding, he wore Captain America cufflinks that gave him, and we have our fair share of Cap memorabilia around the house. So of course we had a little fun with the release of Captain America: The Winter Soldier DVD release – especially since I think it has been the BEST Cap movie so far.

Captain America Party with the BEST Giant M&M Cookie {The Love Nerds} #HeroesEatMMs #CollectiveBias #shop #party

Since I never got to make my husband a giant M&M cookie for his birthday (he had appendicitis over his birthday), I decided to seize the moment and go all out with a Captain America Shield Giant M&M’s® Cookie! Baking this and coming home from Walmart with the DVD basically cinches my nomination for the Best Wife Ever in his eyes.

Captain America Party with the BEST Giant M&M Cookie {The Love Nerds} #HeroesEatMMs #CollectiveBias #shop #party

I love how the backdrop and tablecloth really pop in this tablescape! They also only cost me a few dollars. The tablecloth is an inexpensive plastic tablecloth in blue while the backdrop is red and white striped wrapping paper. Yep, wrapping paper! When planning a party, I always think about the colors that would work for the theme: American red, white and blue in this case. Then, I walk up and down every aisle in the party or craft store. You never know what you will find. In my case, it was this striped wrapping paper that reminded me of the American flag. Cap would totally appreciate that! I felt like the table needed a bit more height to the party decor, so I cut out three stars from blue card stock and used a white paint pen to write CAP on them.

Captain America Party with the BEST Giant M&M Cookie {The Love Nerds} #HeroesEatMMs #CollectiveBias #shop #party

We had a lot of the little party elements around the house, like the Cap Pez dispenser, the wooden peg doll I painted for our wedding, and the Lego Captain America which is probably my FAVE little detail on the table. I also really like how the star cookie cutters looked on the table filled up with M&Ms. Did you also see the Winter Soldier comic book in the back? My husband was so excited to show me that we owned it as I set everything up.

Captain America Party with the BEST Giant M&M Cookie {The Love Nerds} #HeroesEatMMs #CollectiveBias #shop #party

Now – for the yummy part : The Best Giant M&M Cookie! I am not normally a fan of giant cookies. I feel like they are never consistent and can often be too dry. This cookie is super soft without being mushy in the middle. My husband came back for a second slice in the same evening.

Captain America Party with the BEST Giant M&M Cookie
Recipe type: Dessert
  • 8 oz unsalted butter (2 sticks)
  • 1 cup light brown sugar, packed
  • ½ cup sugar
  • 2 large eggs
  • 2 tsp vanilla
  • 2½ cups all-purpose flour
  • ½ tsp baking soda
  • ½ tsp salt
  • 1 cup semi-sweet miniature (or regular) chocolate chips
  • 1 cup plain M&M’s or flavor of choice (Oh, the options!)
  1. Preheat oven to 300° F.
  2. Add a sheet of parchment paper to a 12 inch round pizza pan.
  3. Cream the butter, sugar, and brown sugar sugar together. I prefer doing this by hand but you could also use a mixer.
  4. Beat in the eggs and vanilla.
  5. Add flour, baking soda and salt into the batter and stir until well blended.
  6. Fold in chocolate chips and M&Ms.
  7. Place all of the batter onto the parchment paper and form it into a circle. Make sure to stop about 1.5 inches from the rim and to have the batter be as even in thickness as possible.
  8. If you are not adding a decorative design to the top, you might want to press some M&M’s lightly into the top for decorative reasons. Once baked, you will definitely have that pop of color on top.
  9. Bake on the center rack for 30 minutes and check. You want your cookie to be golden around edges and set in the middle.
  10. If decorating, let your cookie cool for at least 15 minutes before adding the top M&Ms. When you add the M&Ms and the cookie is still very hot, the candy coating will crack slightly.

And presto – homemade giant cookie awesomeness! I definitely suggest drinking it with a cold cup of milk.

The Best Giant M&M Cookie {The Love Nerds} #HeroesEatMMs #CollectiveBias #shop #recipe #dessert

Our niece B is also a HUGE Captain America fan. She has probably watched Avengers more than any 7 year old girl I know. This made her the perfect date for a fun Walmart Retailtainment event. She was able to pick out a Marvel cupcake, choosing the one with a Captain America ring of course. She also got to take her picture with Cap!

walmart collageB loves princesses and totally wants to be Anna for Halloween (can we say the year of Frozen?), but I’ve always found it awesome how much she loves superheroes, too. They are amazing role models for kids. Plus, she is a pretty tough cookie.

Captain America Party with the BEST Giant M&M Cookie {The Love Nerds} #HeroesEatMMs #CollectiveBias #shop #party If you head over to HeroesEatM&Ms, you can take a fun quiz to see which M&M character you are. Plus, you will get to see tons of Marvel ideas in celebration of Marvel Superhero September!

Who is YOUR favorite superhero?! I really want to know! It might even show up on the blog in the future for a different party table because I just love celebrating heroes. 

Have all the DIY tricks and tips, yummy recipes, fun parties and more delivered right to your inbox! PLUS, YOU WILL RECEIVE EXCLUSIVE CONTENT ONCE A MONTH! !
We hate spam. Your email address will not be sold or shared.

Winter Wonderland

Green Apple and Pear Sangria Recipe - A delicious wine recipe that everyone will love with the perfect combination of sweet and tangy. | The Love Nerds #ad
An easy 5 ingredient dinner idea that will make your house smell amazing - French Onion Cube Steaks with Gravy! {The Love Nerds}
Slow Cooker Italian Beef Sandwiches - Nothing beats a juicy Italian Beef! It's perfect for dinner and as party food. | The Love Nerds
Slow Cooker Lemon Chicken Orzo Soup - A deliciously light and fresh soup recipe inspired by Panera's soup recipe. | The Love Nerds
Date Night Cuddle Kit - Create a fun date night kit for home with indoor s'mores, a Not-So Newlywed Game to get to know your spouse more (free printable included), and more! {Love at Home Series - The Love Nerds} #YoursandMine #Ad
Tips to Fight the Winter Blues - It can be a long couple months, but here are some go-to ways to make it better! | The Love Nerds
Crock Pot Chicken Tortilla Soup - Our favorite soup recipe and one of our most popular posts! Easy dinner idea - toss in slow cooker and forget about it! |The Love Nerds
Cranberry and Orange Egg Nog Scones make a delicious holiday brunch recipe! The fresh citrus flavors combine perfectly with the creamy egg nog. | The Love Nerds #ad @InDelight

Popular posts

bacon and cream cheese chicken roll 3
Baked Three Cheese Ranch Chicken - An immediate favorite for my family! {The Love Nerds} #recipe #chickenrecipe #ranchchicken
Delicious Glazed Lemon BlueBerry Scones {The Love Nerds} #recipe #scones #breakfast #pastry
Crock Pot Chicken Tortilla Soup - Our favorite soup recipe and one of our most popular posts! Easy dinner idea - toss in slow cooker and forget about it! |The Love Nerds
Crock Pot BBQ Pulled Pork - Such an Easy dinner idea and Party Recipe! {The Love Nerds} #recipe #pulledpork #slowcooker
DIY Letter Wall - Make a big, colorful statement piece with an inexpensive home decor craft. {The Love Nerds} #letterdecor #modpodge #papermache #papercraft



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge