Go Back
Neverland Pirates Treasure Popcorn Mix - Make a deliciously sweet popcorn mix that is the perfect Peter Pan recipe honoring Neverland's Pirates! | The Love Nerds

Neverland Pirates Treasure Popcorn Mix

Author Maggie @ The Love Nerds


  • 6-7 ounces white chocolate chips or white candy melts melted
  • 8-9 cups popped popcorn lightly salted
  • 1-2 cups of black M&Ms
  • 1 small bag of Swedish Fish
  • 1 small bag of Crocodile Gummy Candy
  • 1 small bag of Gold Foiled Chocolate Coins
  • Wilton Gum Paste and black food coloring


  1. On a large baking sheet or bowl, gently mix in the melted white candy/chocolate into the popped popcorn.
  2. Once chocolate is dry, gently break it apart into pieces.
  3. Add candy.
  4. Make sure to store well to keep it from going stale.